Split's Dalmatian coastline rewards patience, and there's no way around it: nobody flies nonstop between Newark and Split, so business class from Newark to Split always routes through a European gateway, most sensibly Zagreb, Munich, or Frankfurt. United's transatlantic metal gets you across the pond in its Polaris business class—lie-flat seats with direct aisle access on the 767 and 777 fleets out of Newark—before handing off to Croatia Airlines (OU), which operates the short intra-European hop down to Split, typically in a standard regional business cabin with a blocked middle seat and enhanced catering rather than a fully lie-flat product. American Airlines offers an alternative routing, usually connecting through London Heathrow or a European hub, with its Flagship Suite on select 777 and 787 aircraft for the long-haul leg. The honest answer for anyone researching this route: there is no true one-stop nonstop business class product to Split, so the trip is really about optimizing the transatlantic segment and treating the connector flight as a short, tolerable finish.
Having routed through Zagreb and Munich multiple times on the way to the coast, I've learned that Zagreb connections tend to be tighter and less stressful than funneling through Frankfurt or Munich during peak summer congestion, when Lufthansa's hub operations can strain connection times. My insider tip: book the Croatia Airlines segment as a separate ticket only if you're comfortable with self-transfer risk—stitching it into one itinerary with United or American protects you if the first leg runs late, which matters more here than on most European routes given OU's limited daily frequency into Split.
April, May, September, and October aren't just pleasant weather windows for the Dalmatian coast—they're consistently when business class award and revenue fares soften, as summer's cruise-ship crowds and peak Croatian tourism season subside. Given how thin the schedule is and how quickly premium inventory disappears on the Split connector, setting up fare alerts for this specific city pair is far more effective than checking sporadically.