Ibiza doesn't do direct long-haul, and that's precisely the reason so many seasoned travelers get the routing wrong. There is no nonstop option for business class from Seattle to Ibiza, so the real decision isn't whether to fly this route in style, but which European gateway to route through. Iberia's natural strength here is Madrid, where its long-haul business cabin (a mix of older flat-bed seats and newer Airbus A330/A350 configurations depending on aircraft) connects smoothly to a short intra-European hop into IBZ on the airline's own metal — a genuine advantage since baggage and boarding stay within one carrier. British Airways routes through London Heathrow, where its Club Suite — the airline's fully enclosed, sliding-door business seat now rolled out across much of its 777 and A350 fleet — makes the transatlantic leg the highlight of the journey, though connecting onward to Ibiza usually means a short-haul narrowbody with a recliner-style business seat rather than a flat bed. Lufthansa's option via Frankfurt or Munich brings its Allegris cabin into play on select aircraft, a newer product with more privacy and personalization than the airline's legacy business seats, though not yet fleet-wide, so it's worth checking aircraft type before booking.
Having flown this connection more times than I can count, my strongest insider tip is this: book the Ibiza feeder flight as far in advance as possible, since these narrowbody European hops sell out fast in peak season and often lack true lie-flat seating, making your choice of long-haul carrier and layover comfort the real determinant of trip quality. Madrid tends to offer the calmest connection experience of the three hubs, with shorter walks between international arrivals and domestic departures, while Heathrow and Frankfurt require more buffer time, especially in summer.
Seasonality matters enormously on this route. April, May, September, and October consistently offer the best combination of lighter Ibiza tourist crowds and more attainable business class availability, since airlines adjust premium cabin allocation once the peak June-through-August rush subsides. Given how much fares fluctuate across Iberia, British Airways, and Lufthansa depending on the connecting city and season, setting up fare alerts is far more reliable than manually checking — a smart way to catch the periodic dips before they disappear.