Crete's charm has quietly turned Heraklion into a serious warm-weather draw for American travelers, yet there's no nonstop path to get there in comfort—every itinerary in business class from Indianapolis to Heraklion routes through a major European gateway, with total journey time typically running 13-15 hours including a connection, against roughly 11 hours of pure air time. Lufthansa offers the most compelling routing for Hoosier flyers, connecting through Frankfurt or Munich with its Boeing 747-8 or A350 business class before a short Aegean hop onward; Air France funnels through Paris-Charles de Gaulle with its A350 business cabin, featuring the airline's newer reverse-herringbone seats on select routes; and Aegean Airlines, as Star Alliance's Greek partner, handles the final leg into Heraklion with a comfortable regional business product once you've crossed the Atlantic. I've found the Munich connection particularly civilized—immigration moves quickly, and Lufthansa's satellite terminal lounges give you a proper reset before the final descent into the Aegean.
The real insider move on this route is timing your connection through Frankfurt or Munich with enough buffer—90 minutes minimum—to make use of Lufthansa's business lounges rather than sprinting gate-to-gate, since IND departures often land in Europe during the mid-morning crush when immigration lines swell. April, May, September, and October are the sweet spot for this itinerary, not just for shoulder-season fares but because Crete in early autumn delivers warm seas without the July crowds, and airlines tend to loosen business class award and paid inventory as summer peak demand tapers. If you're connecting via Paris, build in extra time at CDG's Terminal 2E, where transfer security can be unpredictable depending on time of day—arriving with a slim connection window has burned more than one traveler I know.
Because this itinerary always involves at least one connection and pricing can swing significantly by routing and season, it's worth setting continuous fare alerts on the Indianapolis-Heraklion corridor rather than checking sporadically—business class award space and discounted fares on Lufthansa, Air France, and Aegean tend to appear in short windows that reward travelers who are already watching closely.