The New York to New Delhi run is one of those routes that rewards patience and strategy in equal measure — get it right, and you'll arrive at Indira Gandhi International feeling genuinely rested; get it wrong, and sixteen hours in a mediocre seat will color your entire trip. Air India's nonstop on this route deserves serious consideration, particularly since the Tata-era overhaul began reshaping the carrier's business class product. Their flat-bed seats on the 777 offer a reasonably private experience, and there's something to be said for landing at Terminal 2 in Delhi without the psychological weight of a connection behind you.
That said, Emirates routing through Dubai remains the gold standard for many seasoned travelers on this corridor. The layover at DXB — ideally timed to three or four hours — gives you access to one of the world's genuinely impressive airport lounges, and the A380 upper deck business class cabin between JFK and Dubai is among the most social, well-staffed flying experiences in the industry. United's partnership routing through European hubs is the more workmanlike option, better suited to those earning Star Alliance miles than to the experience itself.
Timing your booking around the shoulder months — particularly October through early December and again in January through March — consistently yields the most availability and the most generous upgrade windows. Delhi's Terminal 3, which handles international arrivals, has improved considerably, though immigration queues during peak winter travel season can still test your composure after a long flight. Request an aisle seat on whichever product you choose; on this distance, the ability to move freely without disturbing a neighbor is not a luxury — it's a necessity.